How to Optimize Transactional Emails: 5 Best Practices

What are transactional emails?

A transactional email is an automated message sent to a person in response to a specific action or event. These emails usually contain information the recipient expects or needs, such as:

• Order confirmations
• Shipping updates
• Password reset links
• Account notifications (like login alerts or subscription changes)

They differ from marketing emails because their main purpose is to deliver necessary information rather than promote products or services.

The psychology behind why customers engage with transactional emails

Here are some psychological principles you should keep in mind when creating transactional emails: 

• Information gap: People feel compelled to close the gap between what they know and what they expect, which makes them eager to open an email that promises confirmation or access.
• Cognitive fluency: Clear, simple designs reduce mental effort, making it easier for recipients to process information and act quickly.
• Zeigarnik Effect: Highlighting incomplete tasks like unverified accounts keeps the action top of mind until the customer follows through.

How to create transactional emails

1. Select a dependable email service provider (ESP) such as Mailchimp Transactional, SendGrid, Postmark, or AWS SES to ensure reliable delivery and template management.

2. Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC protocols to maintain high deliverability and protect against spoofing. Avoid including sensitive information directly in emails.

3. Design a template that maintains clarity and aligns with your brand identity. Write concise subject lines, and place the core message at the top of the email.

4. Add all critical information relevant to the transaction, including order numbers, tracking links, and reset codes, while keeping the layout readable and mobile-responsive.
5. Track metrics such as open rates, click-through rates, and bounces. Use analytics to refine subject lines, timing, content, and layout over time.

5 best practices when creating a transactional email

1. Use a recognizable sender name and address

People's inboxes are filled with emails. To ensure your new customers can identify you, use an authorized sender name. Here is how you can do it:

• Pick a sender name that clearly shows your brand, like "YourCompany Support."
• Avoid “no-reply” addresses; instead, use a monitored inbox such as "support@yourcompany.com."
• Make sure the email address matches your brand domain so recipients recognize it immediately.

2. Write on-point subject lines

The subject line is the first thing your recipient sees. If it’s confusing or vague, they might not open the email at all. 

Here is how to write a clean and personalized subject line 

• Aim for subject lines under 50 characters to ensure visibility on mobile devices and other modalities.
• Use specific details like “Your order #1234 confirmation” or “Password reset request.”
• Steer clear of words and punctuation that might trigger spam filters, such as "Free," "Guaranteed," or excessive exclamation marks.

3. Prioritize mobile-friendly design

More than half of emails are opened on mobile devices, and if your message doesn’t display well on a phone, there’s a good chance it will be ignored. A mobile-friendly design helps ensure your recipients can read and interact with your email wherever they are.

How to make it work:

• Use a responsive template so your email adapts to any screen size.
• Keep paragraphs short and fonts readable without zooming in.
• Place buttons that are large enough to tap easily with a thumb.
• Avoid heavy images that load slowly or don’t render properly.

4. Optimize your CTAs

Your call-to-action (CTA) is the bridge between your email and the action you want someone to take. Whether it’s tracking an order, resetting a password, or confirming an account, a well-designed CTA makes the next step obvious and easy.

How to make CTAs effective:

• Write action-focused text like “View order details” or “Reset your password.”

• Choose button colors that stand out from the background but still fit your brand palette.

• Add enough padding around the button so it feels clickable and comfortable on both desktop and mobile.

5. Optimize your template

A well-structured template makes your emails easy to read, keeps them consistent across campaigns, and reinforces your brand. A clean, reliable design also improves deliverability and engagement since people can quickly find what they need.

How to fine-tune your template:

• Add padding around text, images, and buttons so the layout feels open instead of crowded.
• Stick to your brand’s colors, but balance them with white space for a clean look.
• Test your template in different email clients before sending it to your list.

Why your transactional emails might not reach the inbox, and how to fix it

Below are some common reasons for delivery problems and the practical steps you can take to fix them.

1. Invalid email addresses

One of the biggest obstacles to delivery is an invalid email address. This typically happens because of typos, outdated domains, formatting mistakes, or misspellings. For example, typing jenna@gmeil.com instead of jenna@gmaill.com creates a dead-end, and the system will return an error such as “email address not found.”

To solve this, use an email validation tool to check addresses before sending. This helps catch errors right away. In addition, regularly clean your database to remove addresses that are no longer valid. A healthy list improves deliverability and prevents wasted sending attempts.

2. Spam filters are blocking emails

Even when your email address is correct, spam filters can stop it from reaching the inbox. It sometimes misidentifies genuine transactional messages as junk if they resemble spam in formatting, subject lines, or content.

The solution is to encourage your recipients to add your email address to their safe sender list so that future emails are recognized as trustworthy. 

Another smart option is to use a transactional email service such as MailerSend, which offers tested templates designed to pass spam checks and reduce the risk of being flagged.

3. Poor sender reputation

Email providers track the reputation of every sender. If your domain or IP address has a history of low engagement, spam complaints, or suspicious activity, your emails are more likely to be filtered or blocked.

You can improve your sender reputation by 

• Sending only to active users
• Avoiding purchased email lists
• Keeping your bounce rate low. 

It’s also helpful to use authentication methods like SPF, DKIM, and DMARC, which confirm to email providers that your messages are legitimate. Over time, this builds trust and boosts deliverability.

4. High sending volume in a short time

Sending a large number of emails at once can raise red flags with email providers. If the system thinks you’re spamming, it may delay or block your messages, even if they’re transactional.

To address this, spread out your sending volume by using a reputable transactional email service that supports email throttling and queue management. This prevents your messages from overwhelming servers. 

Monitoring your sending patterns also helps you stay within safe limits, ensuring emails are delivered consistently.

Final thoughts

As your transactional emails go out, pay attention to the results. Are your open rates and click-through rates meeting your expectations? Are customers engaging with the emails as you hoped?

The data will show you what’s working and what isn’t, helping you refine your messages, improve your templates, and create more effective transactional emails in the future.

‍